Even Neuer won't get 8 or 9s if he's playing v crap
yes of course, but let's say real football has the t11 logic.
Someone who can't watch on tv (radio,internet) the games and reads in the "Kicker" about the games of German league, then he could think that Neuer (few goals but inactive, with rates of 6-7) it's just a ok GK
or
someone reading the "Marca" about the rates of Iniesta (not many assists or free-kicks, lack of defending abilities) is thinking that he is a pretty average MC