The new feature - recommended player

[Ahlony Wong]

Maybe we could switch recommend players?

I still haven't seen any MC

i had...i got MC/AMC this season...and two days ago...the second set...GK (but i didn't got it...cause i already have two 7 stars GK -.-)...
i have seen DL/DML also...but i never use DL or DR ~ so... LOL and so far i got two AMR/ST... one AMC/ST and one MC/AMC in my team...i think each season has about 3-4 set recommend....but 79 token is too expensive...so.... can't get all.... if that is 29 or 39...i may get several more...(at least i want a AML ... cause right now my sub (is from U21) ...is not that fit at all...)

[Tactician]

In my opinion, they are expensive token-wise, but 10 tokens more but without the 'market value transfer fee' for a younger and possibly faster trainer (and an apparently proved player) as compared to those priced at (T69 + market value) on the scouts' page might be a better option. But with 79T, provided that there is enough transfer money reserve, a whole team consisting of five-star and close-to-six star players, can be built.

[Tactician]

Where do these recommended players come from? Their statistics are displayed but there is no information about the teams.

Possibilities
(1) Fake statistics.
(2) Bot teams.

Suppose that a player does come from a team, then it would more likely be from a bot team as a user-managed team would have the option of rejecting the offer which does not seem to be in here.

[Arion]

In my opinion, they are expensive token-wise, but 10 tokens more but without the 'market value transfer fee' for a younger and possibly faster trainer (and an apparently proved player) as compared to those priced at (T69 + market value) on the scouts' page might be a better option. But with 79T, provided that there is enough transfer money reserve, a whole team consisting of five-star and close-to-six star players, can be built.

But I *believe* that his average goalscoring rate will be greater than even 2. My only recommended player I have has more goals per games played, and he was 18T. Around 1.1 goals he scores in a game.

[Tactician]

On overall, none of them are worth it. But if I had to get one in-between those three players, it would be the third one (3rd P > 1st P > 2ndP); the special ability of the 2nd player lowers its desirability. Based on this list only, 3rd P > Scout List STs >1st P >2nd P. Would I buy any of them if I don't intend to buy from the scouts' list? No. So, briefly, this option is like an added option for scout's-list users.

[Bunzo]

They are just generated /made up players like the scout players but younger & easier to train up.


What would ever make you think they came from a "real" team ?


& overall they are worth it

[Tactician]

They are just generated /made up players like the scout players but younger & easier to train up.


What would ever make you think they came from a "real" team ?


& overall they are worth it

But then, the statistics are fake and are probably not reliable. There are strong indications that they are fake; for instance, there is a trend in the ratio goals:assists, and in the number of yellow cards.

I have said that there is a possibility for the players to come from bot teams as some bot teams on the level of the current team I am managing, have 6-star players with special abilities.

Why do you think on overall, they are worth it?

[Bunzo]

They are worth it because any of them I have bought for my teams have turned out to be excellent The one to buy is the 19 year old highest price

The problem is the variation of players recommended

[Tactician]

They are worth it because any of them I have bought for my teams have turned out to be excellent The one to buy is the 19 year old highest price

The problem is the variation of players recommended

Ah ok. Do you have a team page and/or pictures of the of the recommended players (including their stats) you bought?

[talisman]

On the whole, I've been pleased with my recommendation purchases, mainly players with ST role, as at the time that the recommended players were introduced, strikers were so cr*p at doing their job. I could see the machinations in Nordeus' mind - 'let's make STs useless then give the managers a way of getting good ones for more T'...

Palace Casuals have made more use of them, all the high-T (right-hand) players (in order of purchase):



On one occasion a purchase was made of the middle player, but although he played well the first season, he flopped in the next, so he was offloaded (thus confirming Bunzo's recommendation).

Palace Terriers have one (again the high-T (right-hand) player):