4-2 loss in cup against a team with no midfield. Now I need at least 3 away goals.

Any ideas how to counter his formation? I've tried a defensive 4-4-2 with long passing and changed to hexagon in the second half (4 defenders due to injuries and suspensions). Posession was about equal, but he had double the amount of shots and shots on target. He's a little stronger than me.

Click image for larger version.  Name: cup.jpg  Views: 61  Size: 44.3 KB  ID: 62444