Is team quality calculation just.. stupid?

[Cloverfield]

Ok the other things you mention above are completely vague, and it is true that is hard to be calculated cause many factors may be applied.

But for what i mention I think it is a pretty straight forward logic: (example defense)
1. Which players contribute on defense
2. What is their defense q that adds to team's defense q.

It is really stupid that my team's defense q is higher when adding the lower in defense Q player.
It is unrealistic.
I have stronger defense using the worst defender (out of 3)

And it is not onky about calculation.
This also disrupts the effect of training.

Is a defender with high defense Q, better than a defender with lower defense Q but higher on the overall Q?
If not training drills, attributes etc etc are sooooooo cosmetic

[Santa1212]

Ok the other things you mention above are completely vague, and it is true that is hard to be calculated cause many factors may be applied.

But for what i mention I think it is a pretty straight forward logic: (example defense)
1. Which players contribute on defense
2. What is their defense q that adds to team's defense q.

It is really stupid that my team's defense q is higher when adding the lower in defense Q player.
It is unrealistic.
I have stronger defense using the worst defender (out of 3)

And it is not onky about calculation.
This also disrupts the effect of training.

Is a defender with high defense Q, better than a defender with lower defense Q but higher on the overall Q?
If not training drills, attributes etc etc are sooooooo cosmetic

Hi Cloverfield,

I do not think it is stupid, it is just the way the stats have beeing calculated, and you can easily use it to make your opponent underestimate it. The calculated quality of the team is just the average Q of its players. The calculated quality of the player is just the average Q of all his skills. But during the game, the actual skills of course do matter. So if you have defensemen with 150% defensive skills and 50% offensive skills, the player seems to be 100% but in fact when defending, he plays 150%. So the stats can for example show your team is 100% but if you have the right players with the right skills (defensemen with high defense skills, attackers with high attacking skills etc.) in reality your defense is playing 150% and your offense is playing 150% and you win much more easily.

I think this is really ok.

Santa