I have the same situation with two Level 10 3* players, a 30-year-old DC/DMC with Defensive wall SA, 58Q/52%, and a 32-year-old MC/DMC, no SA, 59Q/59%. To a Level 8 manager they'd be 5*, 92% and 99% respectively. Under the old system I've sold similar players first time. Not for obscene amounts of money, but infinitely more than the Agent will give me, and that appears to be the only option at the moment...