Why so many complains about different levels in auctions ?

[fc magdeburg]

By me ... all 18 or 19 years players cost min 20 tokens.

In my case the situation before the update was another. There cost such player max 10 tokens. In the season 1-3 tokens. After the update at the end of the last season, the same players costs between 10-20 tokens.

The result for me: i buy worse players. Or good players for more tokens.

That is my current world.

[goldsilvy]

By me ... all 18 or 19 years players cost min 20 tokens.

In my case the situation before the update was another. There cost such player max 10 tokens. In the season 1-3 tokens. After the update at the end of the last season, the same players costs between 10-20 tokens.

The result for me: i buy worse players. Or good players for more tokens.

That is my current world.

Are you targeting only > 95% 18/19 yo?

Based on my experience price for 80-85% 18/19 yo are much more reasonable. Doesn't take much training to get them to a decent level.

[fc magdeburg]

Are you targeting only > 95% 18/19 yo?

Based on my experience price for 80-85% 18/19 yo are much more reasonable. Doesn't take much training to get them to a decent level.

In the past yes. I waited the first days and then I bought players for low price. For example last season, a 99% GK with a special for 1 token. 18y. I the morning half six. That doesn´t work now.


@ niko

But it's because people aren't familiar with the new system or they 're bidding with no risk, as they believe that they 'll take their token back.

It's not because of the different levels.

Both I think. 1) They don´t use their brains, you say it right, "no risk". 2) In my thinking there are more players ... before update only levels +/- 2. Now, I´am level 30 and fight against levels 4 to open end. That is fact for me.

[goldsilvy]

In the past yes. I waited the first days and then I bought players for low price. For example last season, a 99% GK with a special for 1 token. 18y. I the morning half six. That doesn´t work now.


@ niko


Both I think. 1) They don´t use their brains, you say it right, "no risk". 2) In my thinking there are more players ... before update only levels +/- 2. Now, I´am level 30 and fight against levels 4 to open end. That is fact for me.

Demand has increased (more users/levels in the TM), but so has supply (more system generated players, reset every 4 mins). We are still in transition period, everyone is adjusting. Market normalization will take time before it will find its true level.

Maybe 20-30 tokens for 95% youth is too much, maybe it isn't - who knows?

I'm just standing back, enjoying the view, and waiting for dust to settle.

[Brian Dang]

Why so many complains about different levels in auctions ?
I have read so many comments here in the forum but in some T11 fb groups I 'm watching too.
Is that because people cannot understand how is it works ?
I mean, isn't it obvious ?
A player I can see as 5* and 65 M' for my level, it's 5* and 4 M' for a LV 4 manager who's participating in the auction, or 5* and 100 M' for a LV 25 manager.
The value is relative with the level.

I cannot see why people complaining about this.
What difference does it make to bid with managers form the same (or close) LV than with managers from different levels ?
There are managers who have many tokens, money or a high quality team in every level ... or the opposite.

I though that people are familiar with this, playing in association games vs different level teams.
Nobody is complaining there, if their low LV group is playing vs a very high lv asso group.

The number of the managers who are watching a specific group of players for 4 min, is fixed anyway.
Maybe its 50 or 100 or 200 managers from mixed levels and servers. I don't know.

If we want less bidding wars (or easier auctions) , then we must ask that this group of managers who are watching an auction, to be less.

Every single manager here also knows what is the different...I think In fact you are the one dont get what they are trying to say...
In the old bidding system, at higher level..people will think carefully when bid for a player..but now..we have to compete with so many NOOBs and inexperience managers..They just simply raise up the bidding price and we will never can get a proper way of bidding..
I saw you say at higher level, U dont see many low-level bidders..if fact, it is so many of them instead..I even created a thread with the title : New Auction system-What's a joke..coz Im current at Level 44 but so many even level 2-3-4-6-8-9 managers joined and fight to death in our server bidding War...
I think now U get it? instead create a thread to say something not necessary....

[goldsilvy]

Every single manager here also knows what is the different...I think In fact you are the one dont get what they are trying to say...
In the old bidding system, at higher level..people will think carefully when bid for a player..but now..we have to compete with so many NOOBs and inexperience managers..They just simply raise up the bidding price and we will never can get a proper way of bidding..
I saw you say at higher level, U dont see many low-level bidders..if fact, it is so many of them instead..I even created a thread with the title : New Auction system-What's a joke..coz Im current at Level 44 but so many even level 2-3-4-6-8-9 managers joined and fight to death in our server bidding War...
I think now U get it? instead create a thread to say something not necessary....

You seem to imply a direct 1.0 correlation between manager level and ability to play the game well.

That's not the case.

Experience does help, however the marginal benefit of every additional season is lower and lower.

Based on what I have seen, both low- and high-level managers contribute to inflated price levels.

[Brian Dang]

You seem to imply a direct 1.0 correlation between manager level and ability to play the game well.

That's not the case.

Experience does help, however the marginal benefit of every additional season is lower and lower.

Based on what I have seen, both low- and high-level managers contribute to inflated price levels.

What Im trying to say is they should maintain the old bidding system..level should be with same level bidding..
Not all low-level players are no experience coz sometimes they player other fm game and recently just join this T11 but many does not have it...and if u are low-level player and you feel offended..then Im sorry but im talking about majority..And ofcoz..there are some case the "experieced" players they think that players is good for them..they also will try to bid for it..but if in the old bidding system..we dont need to spend too many tokens like now..that change is only benefit cash cow of Nordeus..

Whatever it is...this is not right..Low level should bid in low-level place and higher level they have their own place...Even now in order to get players with the end of 1-2, you also need to spend 7-15 tokens...which normally..no one even bother to bid...
Some lucky get the player end with 0-1 with just 1 token but thats not all the time...

[nikolgiorgos]

Im current at Level 44 but so many even level 2-3-4-6-8-9 managers joined and fight to death in our server bidding War...

I think now U get it? instead create a thread to say something not necessary....

that's the "key" question.
How many managers are watching those 10-15 players who are in my transfers list right now.
Not from which level or server.

[Mirrowka]

I am completely fine with low level managers bidding same players.... I know they silly (say the least) but hey, every 4 minutes is a chance to get a decent player, I personally like the new system...... and also I like the fact that nobody is clicking on 4 stars players haha and they usually have special ability ... so another few greens will do (especially in young age of player) ... and he is a star ....

ask yourself what is easier to top up a player with 100 greens lets say (5 days of farming) or pay extra tokens which are not easy to get per day ......

You should be happy that no one is bidding them and let them burn tokens for "short solution" like one season is .....

If you can not afford 100 greens for a player, there is easy solution to tank .... and grow them in one month .... (yes you lose only 1 year or an age of player)

If you can not afford to burn some greens, you are simply bad manager, simply as that .....

[Brian Dang]

I am completely fine with low level managers bidding same players.... I know they silly (say the least) but hey, every 4 minutes is a chance to get a decent player, I personally like the new system...... and also I like the fact that nobody is clicking on 4 stars players haha and they usually have special ability ... so another few greens will do (especially in young age of player) ... and he is a star ....

ask yourself what is easier to top up a player with 100 greens lets say (5 days of farming) or pay extra tokens which are not easy to get per day ......

You should be happy that no one is bidding them and let them burn tokens for "short solution" like one season is .....

If you can not afford 100 greens for a player, there is easy solution to tank .... and grow them in one month .... (yes you lose only 1 year or an age of player)

If you can not afford to burn some greens, you are simply bad manager, simply as that .....

yes..guess U are the time free king