Quote Originally Posted by Toxcatl View Post
Are you sure you would be able to note, lets say, 10% difference? Keep in mind that you have to compare with the same player but before he has SA.
I don't think so.
If you feel or don't feel something, it doesn't matter. Feelings lie.

We simply don't know what SA do and if they are useful. Stay agnostic in such questions, because believing is stupid.
Even agnostics choose to believe in something but that is something for another time.

They had them for 2 seasons now so of course I can see if there is a difference (and there is not) and compare them with their old one. ST who scored 6 goals all season still has the same goal ratio. All of them are not performing any better than they used to. I expected to see some of this SA to come handy during important matches or even regular ones, but no, the same good old players resolve the situation, if they are having a bad day than the team suffers.

My theory is simple players with preexisting SA (scouts,recommended,TM) seem to perform up to their task. Players whom I've trained a SA are no different.
And by the way when we spend packs and time to train players SA a 10% difference is not what we want. what is the point of the training then, I could care less if my AML scored 6 goals and now scored 8.