The first game was 3-1 btw
11 fouls 3 yellows, 22 fouls 2 yellows and my star player got injured at 81% condition
looking to your statistics, you just got 13 shots while opponent got 25 shots,
and only 3 shot on target while opponent got 13 shot on target,
you must have used wrong formation and tactic,
to see that different in quality 97.3% and 85.2% is not so big, i can say it almost equal strength,
this 1-5 is the normal result you will get if you managed tour team wrongly.
Orders? formations? 11's? just to know more in detail..
4-3-1-2 against my 4-3-3
Sorry to say that mate, but you are not good at it. As stated above, your win would be a troll result for the opponent. Try to play some other games, you might have more luck there. Or try to learn it, read more about formation, orders, counter formations
I think you need to post more info, and just learn 2-3 tips. You basically are in one of these cases in what you bought an amount of goats, and despite that can have more visual quality, the internal quality is non existent. I invite you to try to follow my advices, after post some captures and I bet you will win a title this season.