Goalkeeper rating and special skill means nothing

[marc31]

I belive that 1on1 GK ability works only against 1on1 ST. Few advantage ability and for each of that is a counter-ability:
One-on-one stopper against One-on-one scorer
Arial defender against Corner specialist
Defensive wall against Free-kick specialist
Playmaker, Dribbler and Shadow striker are more likely skills-ability, and not real advantage like those 3 which can cause a direct-win(with goal from FK, corner...).
In my opinion...

[cracicot]

I belive that 1on1 GK ability works only against 1on1 ST. Few advantage ability and for each of that is a counter-ability:
One-on-one stopper against One-on-one scorer
Arial defender against Corner specialist
Defensive wall against Free-kick specialist
Playmaker, Dribbler and Shadow striker are more likely skills-ability, and not real advantage like those 3 which can cause a direct-win(with goal from FK, corner...).
In my opinion...

SA's are very useful and how worthy they are to you depends on your tactics, formation and players.

I disagree that scout keepers are worthless. They always have 1v1 or penalties and I have saved penalties before, with and without them but, and I hate to do this, real life goalies dont save many either, even specialists like Reina. He might save 2-3 out of 10, when a regular GK might save 1-2 out of 10. Same for T11.

Plus, they are higher skill points defensively, like positioning and handling. So overall it is useful to have the best possible GK.