your data lacking on vital information like what is your both striker rating ? compare to oppo GK (striker really a big factor if your team focus passing to them and they got poor rating means even all your squad got good rating but striker can't finnish the job you will not find a goal)
what tactic did you use ? did you panic changing while watching?
last time newbie complain why he leak so many goal for some reason and rant about it, later he reveal he always use high attacking all the time. duh... big mistake
maybe you not setting to attacking/hard attacking to push more goal, on last minute with 70 more possesion this kind metality the key to push the goal but i suspect it is the striker afterall (i use the same kind formation long time ago. i know what is that formation do mostly)
or other mentality with different pass and mark or other combination. i knew few if attacking don't work some other combination will. this is a big advantage being able to watch the match wihout panic and knew what did you do can secure a win but make further lead need a bit of luck. you can't push if the game decide the oppo GK got his best of his form or your striker got bad day to day which is silly but it does what he does.
this why sub a bad stiker is important which i can't see you subs one. let alone showing what rating he got.