Forum Challenge Season 125 - Assists Challenge

[Tactician]

We could use, only the ratings of 2 players, if at the end of season they r in the top rated of L/CL/cup... and do something there, cause ofc. we cant stay posting here every single rating xD..

so, select 2 players, try the best to make them achieve the best ratings, and only count them if they reach the top. Thats an option.

I spoke for the case of 2 players itself. It will be difficult to track and record them by yourself (but that should be your problem ). Also, it is possible for someone to cheat because you will rely on images of top ratings charts which can be manipulated using an image editor and ratings from another chart.

What are you going to do with those that got knocked out of the Cup and CL/SL early, will you count only the League ratings? What are you going to do for those that got knocked-out of the CL (on purpose or not) and went to SL? Is the average rating not biased (in both ways)? How you are going to count average ratings for those that went to S-L from 3rd place in CL group stage? In my opinion, an average rating competition is complicated and expect contestations or complaints too.

All that being said, you can give it a try for next season and see how it goes.

[gogs67]

). Also, it is possible for someone to cheat because you will rely on images of top ratings charts which can be manipulated using an image editor and ratings from another chart.

.

Has that not been the case with all the previous competitions? The clean sheets and the assists?

[Tactician]

Has that not been the case with all the previous competitions? The clean sheets and the assists?

No. Khris and others can see the profile (including statistics) of the players via the Associations feature. Why do you think the association tag was asked (maybe you missed that)? I personally did not go to look into the profile of others registered players but I am sure some other users have been looking into the others players profiles. I suppose that Khris has verified the winners for each of the past competitions by checking their registered players profile on the last day of the season concerned instead of relying only on pictures here.

For the case of average ratings, top charts cannot be verified by external users and the organiser, hence my point in the previous post.

[Sillybq]

The average rating does not really work very well for some I believe. Not sure if it might create problems for the new idea.
I have a player whose average rating does not change. Played him in 3 full matches which only the first gave him a 10 rating.




This is for league.

[Tactician]

The average rating does not really work very well for some I believe. Not sure if it might create problems for the new idea.
I have a player whose average rating does not change. Played him in 3 full matches which only the first gave him a 10.

I do not think it is reliable too.

[Sillybq]

I do not think it is reliable too.

I did browse through some threads and it’s a known issue. It was a long time ago though. Am surprised it has not been fixed.

[khris]

What about a Defensive challenge? we had for GKs, assists... count the scorers is so common.... but what about earn points somehow using the defense? like MotM 10 points, reach a Top 50-40-30-20-10 extra points... cards could have a penalty... I think a defensive challenge could be entertaining.

[Sillybq]

What about a Defensive challenge? we had for GKs, assists... count the scorers is so common.... but what about earn points somehow using the defense? like MotM 10 points, reach a Top 50-40-30-20-10 extra points... cards could have a penalty... I think a defensive challenge could be entertaining.

Sounds interesting! Maybe every player starts with 1000 points and we minus based on the season stats page?

Less than 50 matches - Deduct points for less matches
Goals conceded - Deduct points

Just a thought!

[khris]

Sounds interesting! Maybe every player starts with 1000 points and we minus based on the season stats page?

Less than 50 matches - Deduct points for less matches
Goals conceded - Deduct points

Just a thought!

hmm but goals conceded could be manipulated same way as the goals we score or so... manipulating avq... and could depend more on this factor, and the GK avq.. etc...

So I need a formula which could allow us to do a valoration only of the defensive line... and could make participants work, so I think that give points to reach the Tops, can be 1 interesting option... too MotM that the defense achieve can be something entertaining to achieve... and discount points from cards earned too is a factor in that case, can not be influenced directly, as cards are something more random, still ofc. play low tackling could help with the risk off conceding goals and have lower ratings... so.... I think Ive the base of what we can do LOL

[Sillybq]

hmm but goals conceded could be manipulated same way as the goals we score or so... manipulating avq... and could depend more on this factor, and the GK avq.. etc...

So I need a formula which could allow us to do a valoration only of the defensive line... and could make participants work, so I think that give points to reach the Tops, can be 1 interesting option... too MotM that the defense achieve can be something entertaining to achieve... and discount points from cards earned too is a factor in that case, can not be influenced directly, as cards are something more random, still ofc. play low tackling could help with the risk off conceding goals and have lower ratings... so.... I think Ive the base of what we can do LOL

True. This will make it more fun for all of us.
Thanks for the effort and time again Khris