Forum Challenge Season 126 - Defensive challenge!

[HeavensAAA]

Khris, just a thought.

Those attacking-minded players (eg. AML/ML/DL with SA like shadow striker) could be competing as a scorer against a classic CD, and that would be very unfair (Wingers scoring twice can already easily outscore any defender in a match on ratings, hence motm). Also some player combinations like AMC/MC/DCM with freekick as SA.

Suppose most top players would be multi-positions, and to strike a balance, maybe it’s fairer to at least exclude all players with AML/AMC/AMR positions? Midfielders do assist and score in matches, but then defenders do with right formation and tactics.

[khris]

Khris, just a thought.

Those attacking-minded players (eg. AML/ML/DL with SA like shadow striker) could be competing as a scorer against a classic CD, and that would be very unfair (Wingers scoring twice can already easily outscore any defender in a match on ratings, hence motm). Also some player combinations like AMC/MC/DCM with freekick as SA.

Suppose most top players would be multi-positions, and to strike a balance, maybe it’s fairer to at least exclude all players with AML/AMC/AMR positions? Midfielders do assist and score in matches, but then defenders do with right formation and tactics.

In this challenge, only DC's, DR's DL's and DMC's can participate. At the end of the post you can see the positions allowed and the min' of matches needed in each competition in order to count.

[khris]

Khris, just a thought.

Those attacking-minded players (eg. AML/ML/DL with SA like shadow striker) could be competing as a scorer against a classic CD, and that would be very unfair (Wingers scoring twice can already easily outscore any defender in a match on ratings, hence motm). Also some player combinations like AMC/MC/DCM with freekick as SA.

Suppose most top players would be multi-positions, and to strike a balance, maybe it’s fairer to at least exclude all players with AML/AMC/AMR positions? Midfielders do assist and score in matches, but then defenders do with right formation and tactics.

To clarify this, due the nature of the challenge -defensive- we cant allow players with multipositions like AM's or evento MCs. The idea is that the selected players should be mainly defenders and play mainly in this particular line.

OFC. We can discuss the fact that... Even with Yellows or red alerta a Dl can play as Ml ir even Aml and could happen that.. achieves a motm there xD so well..

[talisman]

I never check the stats for yellow and red cards. So, if the player get double yellow cards or x2 yellow cards, it's counted as yellow cards not red card in the stats, right khris?

Exactly, as far as I remember it is counted like this.

No, two yellow cards in the same match (=sent off) are recorded as a red on the Player stats table. The yellows in that situation are not.

The yellows you see in the player stats table are only the ones where the player was 'awarded' a single yellow in a match.

[talisman]

Let's give this lot from Nouvion Ville FC a try... Assoc. Tag #QZR8S1

[hudai]

never participated in these sort of challenge. but why not .. Association tag - #TBJ1GB

[hudai]

is it possible to participate with 6 Def player ? as sometimes i need 3 DC.

[khris]

is it possible to participate with 6 Def player ? as sometimes i need 3 DC.

No, 3-5 players is enough. Remember you Will have till day 13 to select the best ones.

[SuperDunk]

I didn t understood the rules completely, but why not...Let s participate
#A4N72A asso tag

[khris]

I didn t understood the rules completely, but why not...Let s participate
#A4N72A asso tag

Still maybe I, will have to edit soon the definitive details xD with the actual idea your DR-MR can't participate btw, it is way difficult achieve MotM from the defense and we know it. xD