Hmmm the first player looks normal to me. Like a typical player who has been with the club since he was 18 years old so his greys drop 20 percent with every promotion. His whites are also common for attackers of active players.

The second player from YA also looks common to me. Many players complaining about the high greys from players straight out of the YA. He probably just added some light training to boost his whites a little.

So it sounds like he is tanking and is your 9-0 defeat against a team with much better white skills than your team?

I am guessing you do not maintain full training bonuses daily and you did not attend those matches you lost?