Formation and Order guide

[TimYoung]

You missed out win bonus.

[Mischa Cali]

You missed out win bonus.

Would be a bit sad if the win bonus makes such a huge impact. The 0:8 above is a huge one. Tho we dont know if the players getting them 5 and 6 ratings have been on a bad rating streak. Still...if the score would have been more like 1:3 or even 2:3 it would be acceptable. 0:8 is just way to high. Thats as if ManU loses 0:8 against Wolverhampton...never gonna happen. Tho a 1:3 or 2:3 is occasionally possible.

[CarlTaut]

Would be a bit sad if the win bonus makes such a huge impact. The 0:8 above is a huge one. Tho we dont know if the players getting them 5 and 6 ratings have been on a bad rating streak. Still...if the score would have been more like 1:3 or even 2:3 it would be acceptable. 0:8 is just way to high. Thats as if ManU loses 0:8 against Wolverhampton...never gonna happen. Tho a 1:3 or 2:3 is occasionally possible.

Look at the home team defense ratings.... there are a couple of 8s and a 7. and they lost 8-0. let everyone judge

[Mischa Cali]

Look at the home team defense ratings.... there are a couple of 8s and a 7. and they lost 8-0. let everyone judge

I just won 5:0 and my GK got rated 6. I don't think he made that many bad tackles

And as for the win bonus:

What i could imagine is that if you play against a lower rated team (quality wise) and you have winbonus set also for normal league matches (always active) and the lower rated team only uses win bonus clever (i.e. against stronger teams or important matchups) it turns into a bad beat...this is THE ONLY REASON i can imagine that this kind of result could be possible.

[PricopGeorgeCătălin]

All guids are welcome and nobody is forced to follow them

[Mischa Cali]

All guids are welcome and nobody is forced to follow them

This comment is so amazingly helpful

We are just trying to figure out what's causing this huge bad beats and none of us is saying anything against the work put in to this guide...so please if you have anything useful to add to this...be my guest.

[kebess]

I stopped reading at:

Defence
How many to play in defence largely depend on how many attackers you are facing.

No kidding.

Also, I can't stand spelling/grammar mistakes such as writing "then" instead of "than". Just can't stand them,

Nonetheless, good initiative.

[CarlTaut]

yeah, indeed, but an 8-0 is too much.
@Pricop: who said he is not welcome to do a guide? i welcome any guide... but a guide should work, there should be proof it works, otherwise it's just against newcomers

[Bibster]

You guys should have a look at his "4132 Guide".

- He explains everything clearly
- The type of players needed to make the formation effective
- The required training for those players
- Counters against different formations, mainly using arrows and orders without changing the overall 4132 formation.

He also provides his experiences.

[Mischa Cali]

You guys should have a look at his "4132 Guide".

- He explains everything clearly
- The type of players needed to make the formation effective
- The required training for those players
- Counters against different formations, mainly using arrows and orders without changing the overall 4132 formation.

He also provides his experiences.

Again...There is nothing to say against doing a guide. Its a good thing. Its only his statement that he never lost to a weaker team which i hardly believe. Its the fact that hundreds of threads are in this forum that say "WE LOST AGAINST LOWER TEAMS" and thats just those that opened a thread. My guess is that this happened to 99.9% of the community. For some it happened maybe once or twice, for others it happened more often. Now I just try to understand WHY this works (as he says) for him but not for many others. Is he that 0.01%? I doubt it.

Please notice that I'm not trying to offend anyone.