OMA Testing Thread - Hard Tackling

[khris]

Here the group:
http://forum.topeleven.com/groups/o-...-tackling.html


As we need to test the game options to see how all really works, I opened a serie of pages in the OMA University group to try to save results and try to have conclusions.


This thread is only for HARD TACKLING experiences.


Today I started with the TSV 1860 München and after 2 matches really I did not notice more aggresive tackling from ma players... 2nd match was the other who had 5 yellows... 1 x2 LOL...

But the idea is test the team and have at least 50 matches with this team to try to see how affect this option, against better Q teams and worst Q teams.


Feel free to participate and to see other posts in the group that are pending to be tested.
I would like to open a thread per everyone if can LOL

[khris]

TSV in cup today, hard tackling, the GK scored in the 87' as mentioned and we won 2-1
Tackling 25 - 17
Fouls: 10 -13



2nd test Friendly

Tackles: 23 - 32
Fouls: 13 -14

More I prove, more confussed I am lol... thats very defensive + hard tackling against Valle de Escotia in Illegal formation....

Follow the melody.

lol

So I play 4-3-3/variations to 4-3-1-2/diamond with Bayern
4-4-2 with Valle de Escotia
5-3-2 with TSV 1860 München


edited:

1st friendly vs Valle lost 1-3

Tackles: 12 -27
Fouls: 7 - 11

[muskrat]

looking at tackles and fouls not just cards would be helpful. unless you are and only showing us the highlight screenshot.

[khris]

looking at tackles and fouls not just cards would be helpful. unless you are and only showing us the highlight screenshot.

That's true, I will do a resume to have all the related info.. lets wait for variations between hard/soft LOL

[Buffs Mad]

The following were done with 2 teams playing 442 in the same Vanilla orders except for tackling







I'll try to post some more later

[khris]

Ok so the 1st thing we can say is that hard tackling increases the % of fouls in the global of tackling,

Lets try to see if Easy = 1/3 aprox of the total tackles, and hard increases till the 50%+ aprox... more tests will be done later lol

[Gert Funck]

don't you wan't normal tackle, so you have all three kinds to compare. This is very interesting

i wonder if

easy => soft

Normal => balanced

Hard => evil/mean

[khris]

don't you wan't normal tackle, so you have all three kinds to compare. This is very interesting

i wonder if

easy => soft

Normal => balanced

Hard => evil/mean

Soft is supposed to be soft as soft is the cotton when touches our skin lol

Yeah.. as nobody know how work really this game I try to know about the sense of the proggramming... lets see what happen lol


For now.. about the tactic orders, I see changes in the bar possession by changeing attacking to very defensive in live matches for example...

About long/short passing I'm not sure, just is a intuition but if, the half of the other team have many players, play short is the good option, and if have spaces and many players in your field, then long.... but... all is to test,,,, test will say the truth lol

[khris]

Ok, league match 1-1 same type of team, with 1 x6*

Tackling: 24 - 20
fouls: 8 -12

1 yellow for his DC left... Nobody attended.

[nikolgiorgos]

Some contribution to OMA search lab
My alt (and also experimental) team, Artemis, from that thread
http://forum.topeleven.com/tutorials...aw-system.html
playing against very low quality teams in the league, with 3-4* teams in the Cup and good 5* teams in the CH.L.

So, I set Hard tackling for my league games (against very weak teams) and normal tackling for Cup and CH.L.
Keeping some records in .xl (red is for league, green for cup an blue for CH.L.)


keep updating ...