Last season..I used this..
Quality about the same 4 both teams..I finished 1st and he 3rd...
Tactic n order: Start with Normal (unless U could not score at 1st half then change to Attacking)/down both flanks/short passing/own half pressing/normal tackle/no offside/no counter
Red arrows on AML/AMR if u dont score...
P/s: Dont mistaken that U must attacking then u can win...as long as your team better quality..u dont need be rushed...
Besides, U also can always used 4-4-1-1 ...red arrows on 2 flanks and AMC..normal also...same order in above...
Good luck,bro