Keep or sell thread

[darrenmcmillan]

The end of season draws close...

So in preparation for the new season if you're not sure about selling or keeping a player, ask for opinions..

[darrenmcmillan]

I actually bought, sold then re-bought this player this season :-)

I am now really pondering selling him. He a few training points away from scout, as you can see I haven't let him go to scout in case I decide to sell him. He has 10 points to spend if I decide to keep him.

18yo, no skill, one position DR. What do you think? Cash in before he devalues or keep him for next season?

[powerzhea]

I would keep him for sure, he is too good to sell, he also is very young, it could be one extremely good player.

[darrenmcmillan]

Another I am unsure with. 19yo scout, high value (fast trainer). needs about 50 training points to be a scout again next season. No skill.

Cash in?

I have a 30yo one on one scorer, and 18yo one on one scorer both world class (normal training speed), so this player is usually a sub. What do you think?

[powerzhea]

Well haha, i would keep him aswell, unless u got such a good team, that are maxed out in stars. Then u dont need him, but if u really wanna get rid of him, i would be happy to take him over hehe xD

[powerzhea]

Btw may i ask, how on earth do u get such players? U pay it with money? Or u find them on the market? What are the levels of your buildings? Do u started playing long time ago?

[dv8r]

What to do with this player?



Plus points -
Young
2 Skill points away from the next star

Negative points -
Slow trainer
No Special Ability

Options:
A) Don't train him ,sell him next season when he's 5*, replace with faster trainer with Special Ability
B) Train to 7* (scout next season) and keep and play regularly.
C) Keep (train to 7*) as 2nd team player and get a replacement with faster trainer with Special Ability

What do you guys think? Any other suggestions are welcome

[July Fourth]

What to do with this player?



Plus points -
Young
2 Skill points away from the next star



Negative points -
Slow trainer
No Special Ability

Options:
A) Don't train him ,sell him next season when he's 5*, replace with faster trainer with Special Ability
B) Train to 7* (scout next season) and keep and play regularly.
C) Keep (train to 7*) as 2nd team player and get a replacement with faster trainer with Special Ability

What do you guys think? Any other suggestions are welcome

Keep, Keep, Keep, I will say it again, Keep... You wouldn't get a player with the same ability/age off the transfer market so easily. Even if you intend to buy a scout to play instead of him for example, I'd still keep hold.

[July Fourth]

Btw may i ask, how on earth do u get such players? U pay it with money? Or u find them on the market? What are the levels of your buildings? Do u started playing long time ago?

There is a thing called "Power Training" you know.

[darrenmcmillan]

What to do with this player?



Plus points -
Young
2 Skill points away from the next star

Negative points -
Slow trainer
No Special Ability

Options:
A) Don't train him ,sell him next season when he's 5*, replace with faster trainer with Special Ability
B) Train to 7* (scout next season) and keep and play regularly.
C) Keep (train to 7*) as 2nd team player and get a replacement with faster trainer with Special Ability

What do you guys think? Any other suggestions are welcome

Keep him till first day of next season, then sell him if there is no one else like him on the market. Wait till peak time people will go crazy as everyone's rebuilding their team.

My reasoning, he's a slow trainer, he'll cost a lot to power train. You'll simply be annoyed in the long run