I have similar issue. Can't win cup. Cannot even pass through the quallifying stage. I regulary loose against worst squads that dont even have players signed, (their formation is invisible) or goalkeeper is playing on strikers position, striker is on the goal etc. I have won more than 15 leagues, 1 champions cup ( + 5 finals that i loose), but cannot pass through the cup quallifiers. My altered team have won 3 world cups and i didnt even paid attention to the team, players, moral,haelth, formation...etc. HOW???