SA has nothing but visual effect?

[HoofDaddy]

I don't agree with the testing done here as it is less than scientific.

They are different positions, different ages, 2 of them are right footed and one is left footed, their previous form was different going into the matches, were you using long passing, short or mixed, like i said, inconclusive based on this test alone.

[HairDryer]

The theory is every player have their hidden ability in them, just that we dont know what it is. If a player have free kick ability in them and you assign that SA then it works if you assign corner SA it become a visual. Same goes to scout either you hit the jackpot or just visual.
Its all hidden just like kris & nik explain.
Visual or nt depend on the player itself.

[HoofDaddy]

It's just a % roll with players fitting into different categories according to their origin.

[vad]

Right, it's cosmetic only. Was actually confirmed by Nordeus a while ago,as I recall.

Same as, by the way, defensive vs offensive mentality, focus passing, and many, many other things, including player's quality. Look at this, for instance: note who is the weakest player in the team:

,

and now look who is scoring:

[vad]

...and here's another one, even more indicative. In this case, not only Nieuwpoort who replaced injured Cardona has the lowest quality in the team, but it's not even his native position - he is AML/AMC, and he went to AMR. But he scores in 3 minutes after that, and then another later

[Ahlony Wong]

don't train SA, use the ekstra 50 skillpoints on skills instead

well... i think some SA is good...in my case.... free-kick SA was my top score in my last 2 season (AMR),
my DC 2 season ago...he is still my to assists in my history.... because he has corner SA....
and header, wall SA i think they are the reason why this season i only have 2 conceded in league~

[Arion]

IMO SA helps for the bench players. For example, your 4* defender with aerial SA can clear corners as well as a 5* defender can do. So it cancels out the quality difference.

[Tyltyl]

I've had mixed experiences with SA, but mostly positive than negative. Surely CK and FK specialists have helped scoring, but still I have no proof that I wouldn't have scored without SA Then, maybe my ML and MR as dribbler have always been very dangerous.

The worst for me has been the PK expert, they have missed a lot of penalties and even made me lose a cup final at the penalty kicks shootout.

[Ahlony Wong]

I've had mixed experiences with SA, but mostly positive than negative. Surely CK and FK specialists have helped scoring, but still I have no proof that I wouldn't have scored without SA Then, maybe my ML and MR as dribbler have always been very dangerous.

The worst for me has been the PK expert, they have missed a lot of penalties and even made me lose a cup final at the penalty kicks shootout.

yes...PK expert always miss the penalties...LOL well... but i always start the first one with my most truth player...like the top score in the season~

[Joseph Sjarifudin]

For my team, FK & Corner SA work good, and also 1 player with penalty kick, he never miss while take penalty

75%+ goal from FK


All assist from corner