Recommended Players - Goalkeepers!

[naimcyk]

Why am i getting only GKs for my recommended players? This has been going on for many seasons now...is this normal?

[Gert Funck]

Why am i getting only GKs for my recommended players? This has been going on for many seasons now...is this normal?

Because the system is faulty. They are looking into it. Words from Moi speaker for development

[Moi]

It's not faulty but needs improvement

Maybe you only have one GK in your team and the Assistant thinks you need more! Try having 2 before he comes back the next time.

[Al Svanberg]

It's not faulty but needs improvement

Maybe you only have one GK in your team and the Assistant thinks you need more! Try having 2 before he comes back the next time.

This is my last recommendation. I had one 6 star fast trainer, 2 scout recommendation strikers I bought, and a bunch of other strikers on the roster and still only got strikers recommended to me (I have only been recommended strikers since I started playing):


I would love more of a mix! Why not 3 different positions each time?

My coaching style is said to be "very offensive", does this impact what type of players I get recommended?

[Buffs Mad]

GK is the default recomendation if nothing is needed.
ST seems next in line.
If you want a striker recommendation then have 2 GKs in your team, only 2 strikers in squad and put both in formation overnight (for my time). As long as you have a sub covering each other area then you should get 3 strikers popping.

You can change this to suit other positions.
The only recommendation that seems problemmatic for me is DMC - but thats my squad issue. Because I dont habe DML or DMR I only get offered 1 DMC and the other 2 those wingbacks.

Thats how to do it - whether its wise to do it is another matter. Personally I wouldn't 'recommend' them unless you have zero access to packs.

PS. It would ofc be nice if we could set some areas we want recommendations for.

PPS. low * players are not helpful for blocking certain types of recommendation - a 6* 1st team GK and 1* GK will not block the recommendation.

PPPS. Ofc if you ask support how it works they'll give you a long story about the assistant out searching for players and being limited by the players released by other teams - I even got a quote that players are not generated from thin air. >.<

[Al Svanberg]

GK is the default recomendation if nothing is needed.
ST seems next in line.
If you want a striker recommendation then have 2 GKs in your team, only 2 strikers in squad and put both in formation overnight (for my time). As long as you have a sub covering each other area then you should get 3 strikers popping.

You can change this to suit other positions.
The only recommendation that seems problemmatic for me is DMC - but thats my squad issue. Because I dont habe DML or DMR I only get offered 1 DMC and the other 2 those wingbacks.

Thats how to do it - whether its wise to do it is another matter. Personally I wouldn't 'recommend' them unless you have zero access to packs.

PS. It would ofc be nice if we could set some areas we want recommendations for.

PPS. low * players are not helpful for blocking certain types of recommendation - a 6* 1st team GK and 1* GK will not block the recommendation.

PPPS. Ofc if you ask support how it works they'll give you a long story about the assistant out searching for players and being limited by the players released by other teams - I even got a quote that players are not generated from thin air. >.<

Ok, I understand how the creators have thought when scripting this. But it is pretty complicated obviously and a lot of people seem to have a problem of only getting one type of recommendations. For me its obviously not working like its ment to work since I only have one striker in my formation and got new strikers recommended for me despite having three 6 star strikers on my team, one on the field and two on the bench.

Wouldn't a very easy fix be to rotate the recommendations if a player at a certain position is bought?

[Gert Funck]

This is my last recommendation. I had one 6 star fast trainer, 2 scout recommendation strikers I bought, and a bunch of other strikers on the roster and still only got strikers recommended to me (I have only been recommended strikers since I started playing):



I would love more of a mix! Why not 3 different positions each time?

My coaching style is said to be "very offensive", does this impact what type of players I get recommended?

I have gotten Keepers every single time since this was introduced, I have both had one and two good keepers at times, nothing changed..

Last time i got a differnt player, for the first time

So faulty or need tweaking, point is that the selection for the recommend player does not work or help squad

[Buffs Mad]

I cant say I unlocked a secret.

It doesn't work very well because most of the time you have to create a weakness in the squad to get the type of player you want.

All I can say is I returned to the game and my 3* squad, and got a 3, 4 & 5 * recommended MC for obvious reasons since I only had 2, weirdly.
I filled out my team but only had 1 GK and got GKs only.
I then had my 3 stooges reinstated, 1 a gk and still I got GKs.
So I bought a 5* GK and got AMR/ST.
I also had not sub wingers at the time.
My friend Peter asked how I avoided GKs and I told him but suggested he wait.
I then had a long exchange with support trying to grab snippets of info.
I told him again and recommended the 2 ST option too.
He got ST recommendations.
He's had GKs ever since apart from when he wanted another ST

As I said I then modified it to try to get a DMC, twice, and I did but only one player each time had DMC and it was a crappy DML/DMC........

Experiences vary but I could replicate this repeatedly. However I'm so over recommendations.

PS. Since the ST nerf (I think) I got a 79T guy that couldn't hit a coo's arse with a banjo. The pain of seeing him in my squad was greater than the waste so I sold him on the market and got 150m for him.....hope things turned out well.

[Nick Lizas]

I have gotten Keepers every single ti:
So faulty or need tweaking, point is that the selection for the recommend player does not work or help squad

everyone is lost the point why not proposal the players we want like in
federations and nordeus: will have
profit because purchases will be made

[Nick Lizas]

for examble i can apply like that

just mark what posision you need!