[Official] Top Eleven 2018 - Main Feedback Thread

[nash123]

1. Thoughts on the new update.

+) I like the idea of the new formation system. It feels like more natural and it could be really nice, BUT
-) it seems to be cosmetic only and/or buggy like hell. pls click for more details

-) the new look of line-up looks ugly (bold?)

-) removed the very good "set-piece taker"-system. Now... only one per set piece is... stupid - especially, you had a good system

-) Goals/Assists count randomly (click for more details)

+-) cap for skills may be good to avoid the mutants, BUT
-) either the drills (with their skills) and/or the skill system (still getting %, if you reached the cap) is foolish in this case. I know, that an update will come, but you the whole way you did it, isn't well thought.


2. Questions.

What about a compensation for manager, who had players with DR/DMR and DL/DMR -> if you think of 50 green packs per position... that's a lot (in my case 200 packs). If you take this to €: ~25€. If you don't give that packs back, why? Explain, why you stealing money?

What does in this game matters (foot, height, weight,...)?

Does it matter, if a player is putting 2mm forward/backwards?

Do the skills in any way matter? Or does only the summery of defense, attack, physics count?

Do special abilites matter in any case?

Why did you remove arrows?

Why are unmanaged/unwatched/dead teams often stronger than managed teams?

Why the simulations don't match with stats (often my team attack the whole time, but at stats opponent, has more shots/SoT, without a single animation)?

Why not a useful skill system instead of cap the skills like I mentioned here:

7.) I don't have a problem with a cap, even it's so low, but the solution wasn't well thought. Maybe you tell Arjen Robben, he was too fast (he had 500% sprint, for sure)...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gAPxcVioyQk

Now, good manager will get attacker and defender with 340% at speed... a bit boring, if the defender runs exactly same speed... (this situation would never been thrilling)
But... with a useful skill system, where 1% at dribbling is a penalty, Robben would never score this goal. He never could stop the ball. He only would run off the pitch.

3. Suggestions & Reasons for the suggestions.

Give us more substitutes to matches (like friendlies). With a bigger squad we have more room for specialists.

Make a beta server and let us test the updates, if you can't. In this forum are a lot of good managers, a lot of people, who like(d) your game, but with such an stupid update (and I don't talk about the new system itself, I talk about the bugs), you destroy the game.
--> you are the developers, but that doesn't mean, that every idea of you is good.
(to be fair: you made some nice things like the events, weekly reward system,... but you also make nonsense like killing club history, flag room, "fans",...)

Improve simulation

Statistics during the game need real time updates

add to all time club history, a counter or a trophy for triples (that would be nice)

[ibangali]

So here goes! Please share your thoughts with us under the following structure:

Bring back 2017, work on 2018, fix the bug test it, implement end users suggestions

Long story short, dump 2018 (vomiting)

[LeManiaque]

I'm with madflo, if you Nordeus assholes can't parse the mountains of backlash and feedback mangers provide you into anything more competent and compelling than this, you don't want our voices anyways.

Here's a thought:

NORDEUS, why don't YOU tell us what you are thinking about doing? then we can tell you beforehand how that is going to mess everything up and why it isn't what we want? You can't listen, you can't incorporate feedback, you hardly compromise, you can't fulfill the desires of the audience here. If you were a boyfriend, you would be dumped and I would warn my friends.

You can't share concepts or goals before they are too far gone, you can't release your beta iterations soon enough to avoid mega fail update releases. You can't control your program enough to combat cheats and loopholes and instead cave after ages of fumbling.

You don't give a ****, I don't give a ****.

[Sai Sátt]

I'm with madflo, if you Nordeus assholes can't parse the mountains of backlash and feedback mangers provide you into anything more competent and compelling than this, you don't want our voices anyways.

Here's a thought:

NORDEUS, why don't YOU tell us what you are thinking about doing? then we can tell you beforehand how that is going to mess everything up and why it isn't what we want? You can't listen, you can't incorporate feedback, you hardly compromise, you can't fulfill the desires of the audience here. If you were a boyfriend, you would be dumped and I would warn my friends.

You can't share concepts or goals before they are too far gone, you can't release your beta iterations soon enough to avoid mega fail update releases. You can't control your program enough to combat cheats and loopholes and instead cave after ages of fumbling.

You don't give a ****, I don't give a ****.

U got to the point.. love it!

Sent from my MI MAX 2 using Tapatalk

[Sai Sátt]

I'm with madflo, if you Nordeus assholes can't parse the mountains of backlash and feedback mangers provide you into anything more competent and compelling than this, you don't want our voices anyways.

Here's a thought:

NORDEUS, why don't YOU tell us what you are thinking about doing? then we can tell you beforehand how that is going to mess everything up and why it isn't what we want? You can't listen, you can't incorporate feedback, you hardly compromise, you can't fulfill the desires of the audience here. If you were a boyfriend, you would be dumped and I would warn my friends.

You can't share concepts or goals before they are too far gone, you can't release your beta iterations soon enough to avoid mega fail update releases. You can't control your program enough to combat cheats and loopholes and instead cave after ages of fumbling.

You don't give a ****, I don't give a ****.

Finally, Nordeus is '****'.

[Sean Quinn]

How about reducing the amount of times a substitution can be made - with the same player!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Sai Sátt]

How about reducing the amount of times a substitution can be made - with the same player!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Update version always make us surprise of bad algorithm

Sent from my MI MAX 2 using Tapatalk

[LeManiaque]

Thought: I think whoever came up with the user interface graphic design is the same who came up with the stars graphic design.

Question: why are they working for you?

Suggestion: fire them. You put player names under managers fingers, how aware does one need to be to understand what an incompetent design choice that is? Tiny fonts, changing layout orientations. "Control grid" system unfriendly to colorblind... They wrote their own resignation letter.

[sincity]

What I don't like most is that I can't see player ratings during live games. Or maybe I just don't know how to do it? Anyone know if it is still possible. I can see opponent't ratings, but not mine

[ibangali]

What I don't like most is that I can't see player ratings during live games. Or maybe I just don't know how to do it? Anyone know if it is still possible. I can see opponent't ratings, but not mine

During the live match you can see 'Emblems', top right corner beside the ass manager comment icon, you need to press that emblems to see your or oppo players rating etc.