Hope you don't leave. Hard to tell about the quality difference, really. it looks like a solid 30% advantage, but you can't tell from stars alone. I have a 38 rated MC who I use as an attacker and his attack/physical skills are both 45+ - so he's a 4* with 6* ability as an attacking midfielder. Most of my defensive players are 8-10 points above their star level in defense/physical. So the stars can lie. And yeah, 3 wide defenders is an open door, in my opinion.