When you reach 180% you get the 10th star, it's just not displayed as a 10th star. But when reaching this max % on one of your players, he levels up another star, which also counts for the other task for example.

Here is a picture from the message you get, it's from one of my players from last season.

Click image for larger version.  Name: Levelup.PNG  Views: 152  Size: 16.5 KB  ID: 135921