You are playing vs +1LV oppos, right? your team avq and the avqs of your last oppos where you got those ratings? or last 3 at least.
You have a good team but your problem here is the age, and this means that each season is more hard to create a distance vs your opponents.
The Beatability Margin that decides the scenario parameters is always based on the AvQ vs AvQ distance, btw and without 10's this can mean different things, cause you may not be allowed to get'em simply, by the AvQ distance, too cause you don't get a key player in reality, as noone earner at least x2 9's or a combination where during 2 matches there are max. ratings earned.
IDK your season stats, shouldnt be that bad, but initially, your players don't have dominant power if noone is capable to perform superb for 2 matches in arow...
Not sure where you found these players btw, fast trainers criteria when searching?