Table of Counter Formations v2.0 - Which formation to use?

[Cloverfield]

4-2MC-3w-1 my oppo, playing attacking style I think.

Tried with 4-5-1v, game was close but he had many shots.
At some point my assistant told me that it is better to play from the middle as flank passes are getting intercepted.

So I consider playing 4-4-2nd next leg, it is a system that I never use but it may suits now.
Any thoughts/advice?