Table of Counter Formations v2.0 - Which formation to use?

[Houzz]

butter fly > 4-2MC-3WAM-1 dude

whole pitch
direction mix
pass mix

[Toxcatl]

butter fly > 4-2MC-3WAM-1 dude

whole pitch
direction mix
pass mix

How do you know it? Butterfly is weak against counter-attacks through the middle, and you suggest to play it against clearly defensive formation.
Why do you need DML/R here? Why not 4 defenders (which helps to defend between simulations) and DMC to stop his counter-attacks?

[Houzz]

How do you know it? Butterfly is weak against counter-attacks through the middle, and you suggest to play it against clearly defensive formation.
Why do you need DML/R here? Why not 4 defenders (which helps to defend between simulations) and DMC to stop his counter-attacks?

This formation focus on mix, so butter fly can block winger then attack winger. 3DC is enough and dont need DMC

[Toxcatl]

This formation focus on mix

No, against butterfly it can (and should) be played through the middle with defensive ML and MR.