Table of Counter Formations - What to use?

[July Fourth]

May I have a question I'm not a fan of counter formations, who do you know which work against other? I mean nobody proved that.

I wasn't a big fan of counter formations either, but with all those posts in the How to win against any formation thread or various other how to beat this formation, It helps if we can devise some sort of table if they want to improve chances of winning against various formations, I've played about and switched formations in important cup games last season and it does help.

[Dorin Marinescu]

In your opinion, what would be a good counter against 4 - 1dmc-2mc-2amc-1? Both teams are about the same strength. From the defensive point of view is enough 4 defenders + 1 dmc?

Is for a cup match, first leg was 1-1 away. I'm thinking to play 4-1-4-1 or 4-5-1 v style, defensive+counter attack+down both flanks.
Another idea would be a more attacking formation like 3N-1dmc-4-2 with red arows on ml/mr, but being a cup game i incline tp play safer, at least in the first half.

Any opinions?

[Dorin Marinescu]

In your opinion, what would be a good counter against 4 - 1dmc-2mc-2amc-1? Both teams are about the same strength. From the defensive point of view is enough 4 defenders + 1 dmc?

Is for a cup match, first leg was 1-1 away. I'm thinking to play 4-1-4-1 or 4-5-1 v style, defensive+counter attack+down both flanks.
Another idea would be a more attacking formation like 3N-1dmc-4-2 with red arows on ml/mr, but being a cup game i incline tp play safer, at least in the first half.

Any opinions?

C'mon guys, anyone with an idea?

[lio72700]

3n-4-1-2?

[Awglan]

3n-4-1-2?

I'd like to know what to use aswell.