I started a thread on rating not long ago and complained about rating via their twitter account recently, saying that players who scores a winner gets a 5-6 rating, which rarely would be the case if the game had better logic built in.

Their reply was that because the player may have missed 7-8 chances prior to that, or was quiet either side of the time he scored the goal, he doesn't deserve a 7 or 8.

I've had players scoring goals getting 5-6 rating.

Seems like T11 has already marked certain players to get low rating regardless of goals/assists.