The most important aspect you must consider when looking at ratings is.....you do not have access to all the factoirs that generated the ratings. Commentary is a merely a small highlights package. Imo there is nothing wrong with GK or DMC ratings - or MCs for that matter.
yeah, it's hard to find a place in the world of t11, players like Neuer, Mascherano or Iniesta.
There is a work to do about the rates, specially in those positions (commentary, different statistics board for Def. & GK).
Ok, about my main team NIK F.C. , rates favor the scorers

Click image for larger version.  Name: NIK lv12 rates.jpg  Views: 43  Size: 42.2 KB  ID: 45388

Click image for larger version.  Name: NIK NEYMAR 1.jpg  Views: 43  Size: 79.4 KB  ID: 45389
Click image for larger version.  Name: NIK ADEMIR 1.jpg  Views: 43  Size: 81.6 KB  ID: 45390
Click image for larger version.  Name: NIK GARINCHA 1.jpg  Views: 43  Size: 80.9 KB  ID: 45391

no4 & 5 are defenders.