Mythbusters of top eleven

[nikolgiorgos]

I say it's very plausible

Sure it is

and btw, I organized the first page with the summary and now you can see the subjects of the thread and the relative # posts.
Need a little bit more work.

[nikolgiorgos]

Let's talk about another interesting thing.
If some of you, playing many games in the Cup and CH.L., did you notice the stats of your players near the end of the season ?
Did you notice some players have much better stats in one of the three competitions ?
Of course this this thing it's more obvious in attackers were we can see the goals and the assists (and maybe in some MCs).
I 've played many times in finals so before that, I take a look at the stats of my players.
If I have to choose between two good players for the started squad, I also use this criterion.
Who is performing better in this specific competition (Cup or CH.L.) .
Myth or not ?

[ponzu]

I do the same thing. I think maybe the league stats is simply a better/more accurate indicator. I think in Cup and CL teams are mismatched more often than not, at least on my level. You either win big or you lose and you're out. Therefore
the stats especially in the Cup are always exaggerated. Multigoal games, great form. Once you're out, the stats remain great looking.

It's not that I pick players based on their stats in the specific competition. It's just that I always give league stats more weight.

[nikolgiorgos]

CH.L. maybe is the most difficult competition, I mean playing with many (in %) good q teams but still you can observe some players with better stats in CH.L. than the league or an (easy) Cup.

[ponzu]

CH.L. maybe is the most difficult competition, I mean playing with many (in %) good q teams but still you can observe some players with better stats in CH.L. than the league or an (easy) Cup.

At least in my experience (and I am only up to LV 9, mind you) the group in CL usually has two weak teams that allows my players to run up the stats. Once we are out of the group (I have never not won group yet), it may be one more easy round (playing the 2nd place group qualifier). After that, either more glorious wins, or a painful loss. Either way, the stats in CL look great, much better than in the League that drags own and tends to seesaw up and down.

[Arion]

CH.L. maybe is the most difficult competition, I mean playing with many (in %) good q teams but still you can observe some players with better stats in CH.L. than the league or an (easy) Cup.

Actually, it's the easiest, even though the probability of winning it is 1 in a 112, as you face only 7 opponents or even 6 if you make it to the final. Cup is also quite par to CL, since you face 7, despite the odds of 1/128. The league, even tho the odds are 1/14, you face 13 opponents. In cup and CL so can happen that 2 strong teams are drawn in the same tie, and it makes life a bit easier. I guess that's why I've won 2 Cups, 1 CL and 0 League (3-times runner up) in the past 7 seasons.

[Tactician]

Actually, it's the easiest, even though the probability of winning it is 1 in a 112, as you face only 7 opponents or even 6 if you make it to the final. Cup is also quite par to CL, since you face 7, despite the odds of 1/128. The league, even tho the odds are 1/14, you face 13 opponents. In cup and CL so can happen that 2 strong teams are drawn in the same tie, and it makes life a bit easier. I guess that's why I've won 2 Cups, 1 CL and 0 League (3-times runner up) in the past 7 seasons.

The probabilities of winning are unlikely to be the same or close to the same as the 'raw' probabilities for each competition. This will vary from server to server and batch to batch.

In my opinion, if a manager plays as he is expected to play, that is, no tanking, built a team capable of winning the all concerned competitions in the previous season, and no 'draw fooling' for the next season, the Cup is usually the most difficult to win the following season but also brings significantly more money as the team advances in the competition. But, this might vary from server to server, batch to batch and league to league (average level of the league, and opponents having the highest quality). A user who manages a team who plays in a league that 50-60% quality is enough to win it, will unlikely build a 6-star team or above, and hence, will probably have an easier Cup draw the following season. A user who is usually associated with a lower quality batch in the server (usually due to frequent poor quality, poor management and so on), will likely to have an easier Cup if he improve his team quality significantly at the start of one particular season after the cup draw. Of, course, his team will likely change batch in the following season.

The Cup can also be one of the easiest to win too, but in this case, it is unlikely that it will have good money prizes.
A user whose team has been among the lower qualities relative to the levels and leagues he has been involved with in the past seasons, will likely to have an easy Cup Competition next season. A user who just 'revived' an abandoned team will likely to have an easy Cup competition.


Generally, knockout competitions are more difficult to win because each round consists of only 2 matches as deciders, except the final, while the league consists of 26 matches counted as a whole for 'decider'. So, you cannot afford an error or a slip in knock-out competitions, and also the so called 'roll of the dice' if ever it is present in the game, will have a more significant effect, while in the league you can catch up, especially if it's in week 1-2. Also, in knock-out competitions, once you lost a round, the competition finished for your team for the particular season, independent of what the results of the next rounds will be, while in the league, its can be said that it is never finished until the last day or until the leading team has reached a certain amount of points.

In the higher levels, all competitions seem difficult to win, because the higher the level you go, the more likely you will meet a serious, challenging manager, and also more likely you will meet those 7-9 stars teams.

[Arion]

The probabilities of winning are unlikely to be the same or close to the same as the 'raw' probabilities for each competition. This will vary from server to server and batch to batch.

In my opinion, if a manager plays as he is expected to play, that is, no tanking, built a team capable of winning the all concerned competitions in the previous season, and no 'draw fooling' for the next season, the Cup is usually the most difficult to win the following season but also brings significantly more money as the team advances in the competition. But, this might vary from server to server, batch to batch and league to league (average level of the league, and opponents having the highest quality). A user who manages a team who plays in a league that 50-60% quality is enough to win it, will unlikely build a 6-star team or above, and hence, will probably have an easier Cup draw the following season. A user who is usually associated with a lower quality batch in the server (usually due to frequent poor quality, poor management and so on), will likely to have an easier Cup if he improve his team quality significantly at the start of one particular season after the cup draw. Of, course, his team will likely change batch in the following season.

The Cup can also be one of the easiest to win too, but in this case, it is unlikely that it will have good money prizes.
A user whose team has been among the lower qualities relative to the levels and leagues he has been involved with in the past seasons, will likely to have an easy Cup Competition next season. A user who just 'revived' an abandoned team will likely to have an easy Cup competition.


Generally, knockout competitions are more difficult to win because each round consists of only 2 matches as deciders, except the final, while the league consists of 28 matches counted as a whole for 'decider'. So, you cannot afford an error or a slip in knock-out competitions, and also the so called 'roll of the dice' if ever it is present in the game, will have a more significant effect, while in the league you can catch up, especially if it's in week 1-2. Also, in knock-out competitions, once you lost a round, the competition finished for your team for the particular season, independent of what the results of the next rounds will be, while in the league, its can be said that it is never finished until the last day or until the leading team has reached a certain amount of points.

In the higher levels, all competitions seem difficult to win, because the higher the level you go, the more likely you will meet a serious, challenging manager, and also more likely you will meet those 7-9 stars teams.

But I've said, in league say I'm a 4* team. We have 2 7* teams. I barely stand a chance to dominate in even 3 of the games. But in a CL knockout round, say those 2 giants draw each other, and I'm in a different bracket. Even if I meet 'em in the final, I stand a chance. I can also manipulate draws, like Nik did. And I've always found a way to choke at league

[Awe Imoleayo Peter]

But I've said, in league say I'm a 4* team. We have 2 7* teams. I barely stand a chance to dominate in even 3 of the games. But in a CL knockout round, say those 2 giants draw each other, and I'm in a different bracket. Even if I meet 'em in the final, I stand a chance. I can also manipulate draws, like Nik did. And I've always found a way to choke at league

Manipulate draws?

[Tactician]

But I've said, in league say I'm a 4* team. We have 2 7* teams. I barely stand a chance to dominate in even 3 of the games. But in a CL knockout round, say those 2 giants draw each other, and I'm in a different bracket. Even if I meet 'em in the final, I stand a chance. I can also manipulate draws, like Nik did. And I've always found a way to choke at league

But then, you are likely to fall in the other categories, which makes the Cup easier for you. The Cup and CL becomes more difficult if you have a team capable of challenging for a league that involves a higher average quality or some opponents having high quality teams in the previous season. Usually, 5-6 stars teams are the ones that face more difficulty in the cup, and sometimes the C.L. 4 stars (especially lower 4 stars) and below teams are expected to have easier Cup competitions, independent of the situation that you have mentioned (2 favourites meet in a knock-out round before the final).