I dont understand this game and i am angry!!!

[Ahlony Wong]

Of course if a team plays a formation where all the players (except the GK) are on the side, then there should be a penalty, but in that case, the formation should classified as tactically inappropriate, and the penalty imposed should be in relation to what is tactically wrong in that formation.

well...i think you have a wrong idea ...this is football... well... what you mean all players are on the side?? you mean if i put all player in the right side and my players are only stick on right side and leave the left side open??? NO, this is football, even you DC will run to the opposite box to pass or shot...they are and they always will, even that is not their primary role. and let say i put AML, ML, AML and DL, next to it I put AMC, MC, DMC, DC and than i put 1 ST in the left front and another DC in the right (or whatever position to put on the right)
yes, 9 of 10 of the players are all at the left "side", but that won't mean the players are not going to run to the right side of the field... (and MC is MC...no matter i put in left side or right side..they are "MC", this same a DMC DC AMC and ST as well) so, why penalty?? i think the only penalty is like Moi said...no defense at all (like 3st, 3amc, 4 middlefield) should have a penalty since no defense at all ... i mean it is depend on the formation (but this is only happen to extreme strange formations like Moi said) ...so putting the player at the side is not a illegal formation

well... and then stick back to what i replied to topic... he was talking to have RED card and penalties (remember what i said...it is with a "s" ) ...
first of all, red card is only depend on what players do on the field, not depend on the formation... so, this is a wrong thinking...
secondary, he said "penalties"... i believe he is talking "one on one penalty face the GK" because it is with a "s" and he mention "punishment and red card" right before penalties ... ( and well, what formation can have more than 1 penalty in relation to what is tactically wrong in that formation...) that was what i was saying "do you know how red card and penalty works in football" to the topic...