Example ? ok
Today in my league game (I 'm staying lv this season so i use some -5* ex-academy players).
Both teams used players in their positions except mine Politis, a DR played in DC position and his Campos, a DC, played as DMC (so it wasn't a big deal).
Click image for larger version.  Name: league 3-1 2 teams.jpg  Views: 147  Size: 47.9 KB  ID: 79180

None of the managers was present. The game made the calculations, added some luck and decided to gave me the victory with a 3-0.
Click image for larger version.  Name: league 3-1 3 score.jpg  Views: 146  Size: 57.1 KB  ID: 79181


My player Oikonomou got a 7,7 (almost 8), with a creativity of 124 (he scored a goal).
Click image for larger version.  Name: league 3-1 3 Oikonomou.jpg  Views: 146  Size: 84.3 KB  ID: 79182
My other MC ,Rivaldo, with a creativity of 172, got a six.
Click image for larger version.  Name: league 3-1 3 Rivaldo.jpg  Views: 145  Size: 82.8 KB  ID: 79183
So what ?
Oikonomou was more creative than Rivaldo ? no
If I had 10 players like Oikonomou with 125 q, the game calculations would be against me, I would loose with a 5-0 or more and all my players would get a 6 or less.
If someone want to see a flea circus, maybe there is