Great post with some very good points in it that I agree with. What I really want to see is a normal manual that explains the basic stuff of the game. I have never played a game for over 2 years which had no clear explanation of what what does. For example:
1) How much does a special ability influence gameplay?
2) If you have a Free Kick SA does increasing shooting help?
3) What is the use of all abilities. If my speed is up to 400% will that mean that I will outrun any defender?
4) If morale goes down, how much influence will that have on a player?
5) How much does win bonus influence motivation?
Etc...... All basic stuff that is never explained. The game is totally random except for the fact that I must be doing something right as I am winning leagues, CL, Cups and Asso's on a regular base.