[Official] Top Eleven 2023 - Player Academy is LIVE!

[royalarsenal]

this is what youth academy coach should be! instead all we get from youth coach is overall training that's wasting on unused skills.
make this feature available to youth academy then i'll start praising top11 & nodeus again.
else this new feature is big thumbs down!

very much this. useful in the academy, horrible in your first team. i'll use the free coaches for bench players that i don't mind missing for a few days, but i won't use it on a starter that is important to my season.

edit: and i do like that it frees up a spot in the squad when you send the player to training. since i usually carry a full squad, in the past when i've won a player in an event i would sell one of my players that i use for daily bonus training just so that i can sign and sell that player. now i'll just send a player to training and then sign the free player to sell.

[Guido van den Berg]

very much this. useful in the academy, horrible in your first team. i'll use the free coaches for bench players that i don't mind missing for a few days, but i won't use it on a starter that is important to my season.

edit: and i do like that it frees up a spot in the squad when you send the player to training. since i usually carry a full squad, in the past when i've won a player in an event i would sell one of my players that i use for daily bonus training just so that i can sign and sell that player. now i'll just send a player to training and then sign the free player to sell.

This seems like a weird bug. So you have 28 players, send a player to training and sign a new player. What will happen when the training is finished? Will you have 29 players in your squad?

[royalarsenal]

This seems like a weird bug. So you have 28 players, send a player to training and sign a new player. What will happen when the training is finished? Will you have 29 players in your squad?

no. i described a specific scenario where I have 28 players in my squad and I participate in an event and earn a 7 star player or whatever (or even buy a player form the auction with a full squad). normally he wouldn't be signed and it would let me know I have 7 days to sign him. well I had a player in training and signed a player and he went straight into the team, I was surprised because I was expecting to have to sell a player in order to free up a spot. I sold the awarded 7 star player right away and he was gone within a couple hours so my squad is back to showing 27/28 so when my player is finished training he will take that 28th spot. now what would happen if i didn't sell the player? maybe my in training player would be the one that isn't signed and I have 7 days to do it. who knows.

[Guido van den Berg]

no. i described a specific scenario where I have 28 players in my squad and I participate in an event and earn a 7 star player or whatever (or even buy a player form the auction with a full squad). normally he wouldn't be signed and it would let me know I have 7 days to sign him. well I had a player in training and signed a player and he went straight into the team, I was surprised because I was expecting to have to sell a player in order to free up a spot. I sold the awarded 7 star player right away and he was gone within a couple hours so my squad is back to showing 27/28 so when my player is finished training he will take that 28th spot. now what would happen if i didn't sell the player? maybe my in training player would be the one that isn't signed and I have 7 days to do it. who knows.

You mean yes. You ask the exact same question as I did. What happens when a player comes back from training and the squad is full with 28 different players?

[royalarsenal]

You mean yes. You ask the exact same question as I did. What happens when a player comes back from training and the squad is full with 28 different players?

your final question was will I have 29 players in my squad when the player returns from training and my answer was no because I currently have 27 in my squad and when he returns i will have 28. i don't know how it would work if I hadn't already sold the awarded player.

[royalarsenal]

i'll add that some of the coaches aren't necessarily a bad deal because it allows you to train with currencies other than tokens and rests. one of the coaches (focused defending x33 min 6 stars) is for 4 days and it costs 90 greens, 108 blues and 270 reds. now i don't value those 270 reds that highly. a player that i would use (if i did it) is a 24 year old 6 star and this coach would take their tackling from 201% to 18-21% higher and marking from 204% to 16-18% higher. because of his age and being 6 stars so the rate of improvement per rest pack drops significantly, that's actually a bad use of 90 greens (yes I know blues and reds are involved but they don't have close to the same value). it's the 4 days away that really suck.

[jarharnamme]

i'll add that some of the coaches aren't necessarily a bad deal because it allows you to train with currencies other than tokens and rests. one of the coaches (focused defending x33 min 6 stars) is for 4 days and it costs 90 greens, 108 blues and 270 reds. now i don't value those 270 reds that highly. a player that i would use (if i did it) is a 24 year old 6 star and this coach would take their tackling from 201% to 18-21% higher and marking from 204% to 16-18% higher. because of his age and being 6 stars so the rate of improvement per rest pack drops significantly, that's actually a bad use of 90 greens (yes I know blues and reds are involved but they don't have close to the same value). it's the 4 days away that really suck.

you're damn wrong. if you train the players by yourself with that same amount of boosters you will get better result. and people are crying bout lack of red treatments because of tons of injuries now

[royalarsenal]

you're damn wrong. if you train the players by yourself with that same amount of boosters you will get better result. and people are crying bout lack of red treatments because of tons of injuries now

if I spent 90 greens (i'll give blues 33% the value of a green, so a total of about 125 greens) on the same player that I'm referring to I wouldn't take his tackling from 201% to 219-22% and marking from 204 to 220-22% and i would have to use a drill like 1-on-1 finishing to get the tackling as press the play is already maxed out for me and set piece delivery for the marking because all the drills that only train white skills for a DC are done for that player.

and my reds are over 750 now and increase all the time. it's the one thing that never stops going up for me. if they ever have a coach that takes just reds (even say 400), i'm doing it without a second thought.

[Subject 117]

This seems like a weird bug. So you have 28 players, send a player to training and sign a new player. What will happen when the training is finished? Will you have 29 players in your squad?

I can answer that. What happened was that my returning player showed up in my squad... but he was very much like a new player. I couldn't use him, I had to free up a space in my squad and then I had to sign him with a new 3 year contract. As it's the case with new players, I also had 7 days to sign him.

[jarharnamme]

I can answer that. What happened was that my returning player showed up in my squad... but he was very much like a new player. I couldn't use him, I had to free up a space in my squad and then I had to sign him with a new 3 year contract. As it's the case with new players, I also had 7 days to sign him.

funny thing is i almost try to send my player to this academy thingy.
but 1st i have to extend my player contract because his contract expires end of season, so if what this guy say is true then i have to use cash (which is useless in this game) twice if i want to re-sign him again after i sell/sack 1 of my 28players (before sending him to academy & after he graduates from academy)