First: this table is just to give you a idea of what might be the Best formation to use, but does not exist a formation 100% unbeatable.
Second: whend you change tactic, you change players to other positions, even If they have double or triple role, normally there is always a position where they play better.
Third: mentality can have some influence in the way the formation can or not work.
FOURTH : This is Top eleven, always expect the unexpected.