Your screenshot number 3 is what I told before. When you train a player on OLD version, depending gap to next star he will evolve to it. So it is easy to calculate when SA is opened. When no SA is opened, you trained him for 12 SP reason why he gets the next star. Only 11 SP would have save him previous low star. Your screenshots just explain my theroy. But my English is not perfect, so maybe I had written sentences difficult to be understood well !?

Quote Originally Posted by nikolgiorgos View Post
Experiment - Ronaldo
1) Ronaldo 5* old
Click image for larger version.  Name: new ST-AMR nord to RONALDO.jpg  Views: 379  Size: 79.2 KB  ID: 63764

2) Ronaldo 5* new
Click image for larger version.  Name: Ronaldo 5star new.jpg  Views: 369  Size: 58.9 KB  ID: 63765

3) Ronaldo 6* old
Click image for larger version.  Name: RONALDO 6star old.jpg  Views: 369  Size: 85.8 KB  ID: 63766

4) Ronaldo 6* new
Click image for larger version.  Name: RONALDO 6star new.jpg  Views: 369  Size: 58.5 KB  ID: 63767