Definitive Illegal Formation Rules

[dafide]

Thanks

[kamillu]

Here's an illegal formation, yet it seems to meet all the requirements:
--- ST --- ST ---
------ AC -------
ML -- MC --- MR
------ -- -- DMR
DL -- DC --- DR


I know you was just testing, but what kind of manager would play with a formation like that?

Just use your common sense and football knowledge and you won't have any problems setting up the formations

[dv8r]

Here's an illegal formation, yet it seems to meet all the requirements:
--- ST --- ST ---
------ AC -------
ML -- MC --- MR
------ -- -- DMR
DL -- DC --- DR


I know you was just testing, but what kind of manager would play with a formation like that?

Just use your common sense and football knowledge and you won't have any problems setting up the formations

A clueless manager. One who just plays the game with no football knowledge. Trust me, there are a few who I have played that have stupid formations

[kamillu]

HAHA, I am trying to think how a real life team would play with that kind of formation.

all other things listed makes sense to me. (a team either plays with DR/DMR or MR/AMR if any)

[Potemy]

Here's an illegal formation, yet it seems to meet all the requirements:
--- ST --- ST ---
------ AC -------
ML -- MC --- MR
------ -- -- DMR
DL -- DC --- DR


I know you was just testing, but what kind of manager would play with a formation like that?

Just use your common sense and football knowledge and you won't have any problems setting up the formations

What do you mean it seems to meet all the requirements? You don't know why the formation is illegal? You sound like you think it should be legal.

[kamillu]

I didn't write the first bit, it was written some way ago..

I just mentioned that it does not make sense to play with that kind of formation, just use your common sense and you won't have any trouble setting the formation.

[Potemy]

I didn't write the first bit, it was written some way ago..

I just mentioned that it does not make sense to play with that kind of formation, just use your common sense and you won't have any trouble setting the formation.

Oh alright. You should have left it in the quote bubble or something.

You'll be surprised what people come up with, though.

[Fenwick]

I want to know if my formation it's illegal or no ?

[Potemy]

I think it's legal, but very odd.

[Ayman]

is this one legal ?