Mythbusters of top eleven

[nikolgiorgos]

Myth: Players bought after the group stage of CL will never rate higher than a 6 in their first knockout stage appearance.

well, that's a unique case, we don't have so many cases (or it's something that bothering players of the game).
But if you noticed that happened in some more seasons, it would be interesting to post some pics.

[Killroy]

Of course you would give him 2 blue packs. Even if the effect is marginal like 1-2% The thing with this game is, that it is totally unclear what certain things do and we will never ever get an explanation of the developpers. This leads me to think that the engine is just a pile of crap and that we tinker around with it, thinking that we might have some influence but in reality....... Still enjoying the game, but don't give it too much attention anymore.

Myth or fact: Wingers have been changed since the last patch. In my hexagon team my wingers are extremely effective. And I do mean extremely effective as in 70% of the goals are scored by them of lately (and a lot of assist) in the last 10 games. My 6 star striker with one on one ability hardly ever scores. He hardly ever gets into a position where he can use one on one at all.
In my second team most of the scoring is done by my MR and AMC. My six striker with FK SA is only at the third spot. Strange stuff.

[lespa]

So, giving morale boosters to players has no affect on players. This is just great! ;-)
After reading all this, the best way to manage a team is to log on to a game, exchange boosters with other managers, not blue we don't need those ;-) and leave the game and log on the following day.

[nikolgiorgos]

Of course you would give him 2 blue packs

Yes is the answer from me too. Every time I 'm playing a final, my players (11 + possible subs) must have at least "very good" morale.

So, giving morale boosters to players has no affect on players.

I think there are many examples where someone can "prove" that morale doesn't affect performance, but I 'm sure, from my training, that bad morale makes my players much more vulnerable to injuries when I train them.
I also considering morale as an indicator that shows in which condition-form my player is. The reverse effect. I don't give booster to my player to play better but I observe that when his morale is dropping, maybe he is coming in a "deforme" period. If he drops to poor morale, then I give 2 boosters to prevent him from an injury or maybe from a fatal mistake in a game.

Here I want to say about the subject of this thread. We have some issues of the game and trying to categorize to those scenarios below
a) One thing has no effect in the game, it's psychological, it's a rumor, it's a Myth
b) One thing affects the game, maybe not all the time but we must always consider this. It's a fact.
c) One thing, has some effect but this is only a +1%, +2%, +3*, so it's lost among other factors of the program - or the roll dice of the game.

[Sons of Pitches]

so what were saying here is morale doesn't really do anything?

[lespa]

so what were saying here is morale doesn't really do anything?

what I understood from these posts, morale boosters do not increase the performance of players just decrease the chance of a player getting injured.

[dave1311]

Player gains another star and just got stronger. Does this have any bearing on his ratings or performances ?


FC Loella. Server 121. Level 23
14 League Titles
3 Champions Leagues
1 Cup

[nikolgiorgos]

ok, let's resume about morale
Low morale has a negative effect in training. We don't power training a player with poor morale (cause of injuries) > Fact
If we give blue boosters and our players have perfect morale and condition, this doesn't guarantee good performance > Fact
A player with low morale can also play good and have a good rate > Fact
Morale can increase with 1-2 good performances > Fact
We can use morale as an indicator, to recognize the "form" situation of our player > possible but more to investigate
Some more interesting questions :
Our player got injured in a game. After that, we saw that also his morale dropped. In an injury of another player, his morale didn't drop. Why ?
A team with 2-3 with bad morale players, can play good and have victories. A team with all the players in bad morale, can perform also good ?

[nikolgiorgos]

Player gains another star and just got stronger

Hi dave.
hmmm, ok, let's talk about stars.
We read a lot posts, here in the forum, saying, "my scout level ST, playing sh..t, while the 4* defender of the other team played great. WHY ?
But let see the quality and not the stars.
My player, Neymar, is playing good this season. He is 4* (actually he is in his first 5*), q90 if I add the sp.



My other ST, Pele, isn't playing so good. He is 6* (actually he is in his first 7*), q100 if I add the sp.



Another player I got a picture from TM, has 3* and q84.




Pele, the 6-7* player doesn't have the double quality (and maybe performance ) from the 3* player.
He has about 18% better quality form him and about 10% better quality from Neymar.
But if Neymar (or the 3* player) is in a better form period from Pele, of course he can perform better.

[dave1311]

Hi dave.
hmmm, ok, let's talk about stars.
We read a lot posts, here in the forum, saying, "my scout level ST, playing sh..t, while the 4* defender of the other team played great. WHY ?
But let see the quality and not the stars.
My player, Neymar, is playing good this season. He is 4* (actually he is in his first 5*), q90 if I add the sp.
Attachment 55184


My other ST, Pele, isn't playing so good. He is 6* (actually he is in his first 7*), q100 if I add the sp.
Attachment 55185


Another player I got a picture from TM, has 3* and q84.
Attachment 55186



Pele, the 6-7* player doesn't have the double quality (and maybe performance ) from the 3* player.
He has about 18% better quality form him and about 10% better quality from Neymar.
But if Neymar (or the 3* player) is in a better form period from Pele, of course he can perform better.

Hey buddy.

My two 5 star strikers are scoring for fun this season. Both fast trainers too so should be around for a while. I decided to blow a few Green packs when I was bored and trained them both to scouts.
I'm keen to see if they get even better than the 9 & 10 ratings they get every game !


FC Loella. Server 121. Level 23
14 League Titles
3 Champions Leagues
1 Cup