CK specialists do not work anymore

[gizzmo]

Sometimes I ask myself the same question about SAs. But one thing is certain: the treble monsters in my last 20 seasons or so all had a full squad of SA players. So, I am doing the same and the result is not too bad...

[Javert89]

My corner kick specialist did big things today from corner

[Cloverfield]

My corner kick specialist did big things today from corner

That was very interesting!
Could you tell me the formation you used? Was he the sole striker in your formation?

[Gert Funck]

Sometimes I ask myself the same question about SAs. But one thing in certain: the treble monsters in my last 20 seasons or so all have a full squad of SA players. So, I am doing the same and the result is not too bad...

Token buyers often have stronger teams skillwise as well, that more than the SA correlation IMHO

[nikolgiorgos]

That's a general rule of T11.
Better have than not

[madflo19]

Never had players with SA for fk and ck,for many seasons i had vanBasten for both,almost all his fk's were goal and his record of assists is 74 in 1 season(half of them were from ck as for the last 4-5 seasons i cut him from ck's and he had around 35-40/season)
Now my ck specialist doesn't have SA but he's very good with over 40 assists/season,this season he has 17 assists in 15 games
For the 1st time i have fk specialist with SA ,his first matches,after i trained him fk SA, all his fk's were out of target,now,the last games he scored all his fk's,i must say that he's better than vanBasten 😉

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

[Javert89]

That was very interesting!
Could you tell me the formation you used? Was he the sole striker in your formation?

Opponent did not have any aeral defender (we know the strength of bot teams!)

[Cloverfield]

@madflo
I never train ck or fk I think it is useless. But I can't say the same when player is game generated and has the same auto assigned. Most times it seems that for those players internal code for sa works.

@javert
Thanks a lot for sharing.
This is one more proof for me that the position of player kicking the corner plays its role.
You had more than one st in your formation, so if one kicks the corner the other is in the penalty area. Behavior is different when your st-ck kicker is the only striker.

For me it seems that position plays a more important role than sa. 1 more corner kick assist from my wing back today!

[woopypooky]

In my opinion, players have a hidden algorithm that refreshes every season, how many goals and how many assisst they can make on certain competitions.

[ibangali]

It seems that is an algorithm twist so when you assign an attacking player for corner kick taker, you blow your chances for corner-goal as your penalty area is less crowded.

Very good point, I never pay attention on that. I might not playing longer than you all but I always make fk, ck etc sa for my players and they are not doing bad. as nash123 says,

2.) Key attributes matters:

so far I remember lots of us share our thought one of khris threat [https://forum.topeleven.com/tutorial...s-thread.html]

one of my club use 3-1-4-1-1, some time 3-1-4-2, 4-1-4-1 and you can see the screenshot about his assist: [name is Jordens van der Plas]

other 2 ck players [Yohan Andonian, Jorge Garrido] mostly play as mr/amr, I use them as ST when I use 4-4-2 ND; but I'll keep eye now to find more data about your point



thanks for sharing your thought