Hi. Sorry for delay to come back and answer !
My theory I checked many times is and remains ONLY IF you train them by the OLD version and come back to play on NEW version. It concerns only those whom open both versions.

Quote Originally Posted by cookizzz View Post
This player has no SA and is 10 sp to 185. I just received an nego offer. So I suppose he is acutally now 1 sp to next star. The offerer is my strong opponent in league for at least 2 seasons. But he is not my friend, so I have not yet accepted his offer, and made a counter offer.

As I understand to Eric Jego's theory or law, once I trained the player and gain 1 sp, he will be immediately added a new star. I am looking forward to verify this. I don't really want my counter offer will be accepted.

Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Caicedo nego offer received.jpg 
Views:	92 
Size:	42.9 KB 
ID:	63742

P.S. The player is still very tired and have not yet been trained in this season because I power trained him to burn out all his conditions near season end of last season before he turned 22.