Testing SA's Thread

[nikolgiorgos]

You know (I think) my opinion about individual skills (that is not important for the performance of player).
Here is a player from a team of my league (RINOKEROS).
This team is a strong one (all 7* players).
Malezas has F-K ability and he 's taking those shots.
As you can see, he has high defensive and M&P skills but low attacking skills.
But he has talent to that.
Also you can observe that he has much more success in League games (where oppo players have less quality) than in CH.L. or the Cup (where oppo have the same quality).



here again, comparing his skills with ahonother player 5*, who is in top5 scorers of the league

[ibangali]

wow, 2 sp popup at the same time

that PM popup from dc+dmc+mc and SS from mr+amr+st

[LeManiaque]

Which positions were they playing in at that match, ibangali?

I have seen Shadow Striker + corner specialist a few times, from SS in MR position

[ibangali]

Which positions were they playing in at that match, ibangali?

pm sp=> my dc+dmc+mc and he was playing as dmc with blue arrow
ss sp => mr+amr+st and he was playing as amr with red

dmc pass the ball to amr and amr shoot for goal
3-1-3-2-1 formation

[nikolgiorgos]

my reserves played today and oppo C-K specialist gave 3 assists from the corner, to the same player (copy paste)
* oppo didn't watch the game, whatever I tried failed


oppo C-K specialist - crossing is his lowest attack skill

[Cloverfield]

oppo C-K specialist - crossing is his lowest attack skill

One more proof adding to the thought that single individual attributes play no role in the game.
The whole average of each category (defense-attack) seems to matter.

Most of CK specialists I have had, gave many assists during the season, 90% of them coming from corners.
But all of them have the SA already assigned on them (either bought from recommendations or nordgens with SA)

So at it seems a bit random factor if he is a good assister or not I would never spend greens in order to assign CK SA to a player.

[madflo19]

So at it seems a bit random factor if he is a good assister or not I would never spend greens in order to assign CK SA to a player.

Both of my teams doesn't have an player with ck sa,in the first matches of the season I was a bit worried that my teams were scoring very few goals from ck's but the last days they are scoring a lot from ck,1-2 goals/day



Sent from my SM-A310F using Tapatalk

[ibangali]

Right, no point to watching the game anymore. This season I'm hardly winning (1:0 or 2:1 or 3:2 etc) with unwatch manager team
My areal defender can't save the ck against unwatch manager game.

[nash123]

At my league, I have an opponent, who has an really good assister - CK.
I don't know, how many assist from CK, but, if you look at his stats, non - for me - important skill to be a (good) CK is high.



My PM and CK have way more skill at crossing, creativity,... but both together haven't 9 assists this season.

Just a thought: what's, if the SA ignores stats? Maybe that's the reason, why defenders can be good FK, CK, PK,... (kayattributes aren't shooting, finishing).

[ibangali]

I'm not 100% sure but over 75%, my understanding about ck and fk skills are:

for ck: passing + crossing + creativity, 3 of these attributes points differ should not be way high (if ck sa assign by you), like passing 100, crossing 65, creativity 50, these points differ may be 20-30, like passing 100, crossing 80, creativity 75, still I'm working to see but need more time but if anyone also working with ck please try those three attributes and share your thought
also I'm not sure ck need finishing or not, my mc (mc+ml+dml) not doing good with assigned ck sa but since I work his those 3 attributes he doing little good but not great, his finishing points not that great, still I'm trying add more finishing points to see that he can do more better or not.

for fk: shooting + finishing + creativity, same in here, each attributes points differ should not be way too high (if fk sa assign by you).