Understanding role of Luck in top eleven

[nikolgiorgos]

Rock Paper Scissors or Weak Neutral Strong or whatever are popular bases for game mechanics.
However imo its not suitable for a T11 model. T11 seems more lick and action/event based similation where the success or failure is based on numerical comparisons that are modifird. Think more of Dungeons and Dragons type mechanics. Compare your attacking stats (weapon, strength accurracy etc) v my defensive stats (constitution, agilty, etc) for each critical action/even. The weak neutral strong are just additional modifiers in the calculations.

well, i believe that TE has more complicate forms of luck than that
for example what are saying, doesn't explain why a normal team cannot win an oppo who set his team in "Wall"
or why I won about 20-25% of my games in league where I made an experiment (using a 1* ST for GK)
http://forum.topeleven.com/%CE%95%CE...ix-result.html

@HoofDaddy

I still don't understand how formation/orders figure into it but it is definitely a deciding factor. I'd attribute the formation/orders matchup as being between 25-50% weight of the overall match calculation.

That's something in my future plans. I 'll play one season with a team, where I 'll set in every game exactly the "wrong" formation (but not players out of position).
I 'll let you know when.

@nash123
sorry about that
Anyway, this thread it's not about to post some "bad moments" of our team but to "explore" the forms of luck in TE.

@Ahlony Wong
sorry for you too
I also read your other thread and I wonder if those goals conceded, (if and) when you used attack or defense +bonus button.
I had some experience to that.